I ♥️ feedback


This week in the world’s #1 newsletter on leadership communication:

  • How to Receive Feedback Without Getting Defensive​
  • On the Show: Why “Keeping Everyone Informed” Doesn’t Work​
  • Book Recommendation: How to Fix a Broken Hierarchy ​

How to Receive Feedback Without Getting Defensive

"I know feedback is crucial if I want to grow as a leader. But I find it hard to hear. What can I do about it?"

Someone asked me this at an event this week.

I can't overstate how important it is not just to accept feedback with grace, but to demand it.

When we do, people invest time and energy in helping us grow. When we receive it poorly, we train them to stop giving it.

So, treat feedback as a gift. But it’s easier said than done.

Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen, in Thanks for the Feedback, explain why even well-meant feedback can set us off. They describe three kinds of triggers (thanks to JD Meier for bringing this book to my attention).

1/ Truth triggers fire when the feedback itself seems wrong, unfair or unhelpful. Our instinct is to spot what's inaccurate and dismiss the rest.

2/ Relationship triggers fire because of who is giving the feedback. We react to the giver ("Who are you to tell me that?") or to how we feel treated by them (“The CFO doesn’t respect me!”)

3/ Identity triggers fire when feedback threatens our sense of who we are. It knocks us off balance, and we either exaggerate it ("I'm a complete failure") or reject it entirely (“I know I am good at this!”).

I would add one:

4/ Delivery triggers fire when the feedback is given in a clumsy, insensitive or formulaic way (like the feedback sandwich). I have written on how to give feedback like an elite leader here. ​

If you are on the receiving end, remember ACE:

Acknowledge, don't defend.

Notice which trigger just fired: truth, relationship, identity or delivery. Naming it takes away some of its power. Then remind yourself that feedback is an investment the other person makes in your growth.

Consider each point on its merit.

Separate the message from the messenger and from how it was delivered. Ask yourself: "What might be right about this?" Use what's useful and ignore the rest.

Evolve.

Pick one thing to work on, not five. Tell the person what you're changing. A few weeks later, go back and ask how you're doing. That shows you listened, and it makes them far more likely to give you feedback again.

Feedback is a real dilemma. It's so crucial to your success and that of your team, but few people like to give or receive it. That's why leaders who learn to receive it well end up getting more of it than anyone else. Next time feedback stings, just ACE it.

Get good at receiving it, and you'll never be short of it.


ON THE SHOW

Why “Keeping Everyone Informed” Doesn’t Work

▶️ Episode 343 on YouTube, Spotify or Apple.

Recently a CEO asked me why his team was disengaged. "How does communication work around here?" I asked.

"When we decide something, we cascade the information down to keep everyone informed."

"That's your problem."

Cascading creates the illusion of communication. In reality, it creates distortion, delay and silence. The important stuff gets lost in a game of telephone.

W. Edwards Deming said every system is perfectly designed to get the results it produces. So if your people are disengaged, you don't have a people problem. You have a system problem.

I learned this the hard way at easyJet, where I was responsible for building the communication systems for 10,000 people spread across a continent. Through hard knocks and fast learning, we created a system that works in a team of five as well as a company with 100,000 employees.

It's called Push, Pull, Exchange.

In this week's video I show you how to set up all three. If you lead people, it is worth five minutes of your time.


BOOK RECOMMENDATION

How to Fix a Broken Hierarchy

Bad bosses. Toxic politics. People fighting for promotions.

Hierarchy gets a bad rap, and often, for good reason.

Nir Halevy's best estimate: one in four employees is currently working in a broken hierarchy. So the obvious answer is to flatten it. Get rid of layers. Give people more freedom.

Except that may create a whole new problem. As Nir told me: "In environments where you don't have one single boss, everyone becomes your boss."

Nir is Professor of Organizational Behavior at Stanford and probably the world’s leading researcher on hierarchies in organizations. He's spent years studying what makes hierarchies work, what breaks them and how we can improve them.

His new book Level Up – Why Hierarchies Are Broken and How to Fix Them explains how we can identify broken hierarchies and how to fix them.

He doesn’t pretend that hierarchies will go away. So the real question is how to make it work for the people inside it.

If you lead people, read it. And if you want to hear Nir yourself, he's my guest on Speak Like a CEO next week.

Have an inspired weekend,

Oliver

Eo Ipso Communications GmbH

c/o Mindspace

Uhlandstraße 32, 10719 Berlin

​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Speak Like a CEO by Oliver Aust: Become a Top 1% Communicator

Join 160,000+ leaders receiving weekly tips via email & social.

Read more from Speak Like a CEO by Oliver Aust: Become a Top 1% Communicator

This week in the world’s #1 newsletter on leadership communication: How to Create an Aura On the Show: 10 Moves to Stand Out Without Looking Like an Egomaniac Book Recommendation: How to Lead Without Losing Yourself How to Create an Aura Hi Reader, "There are people who, when you meet them, you just know. Just the demeanor lets you know that this person is onto some other shit." That's hip-hop pioneer Grandmaster Flash. (I managed to snatch a signed copy of his book at London’s Rough Trade...

This week in the world’s #1 newsletter on leadership communication: How to Speak Like a Spy On the Show: The Trillion-Dollar Cost of Leaders Who Talk Too Much Book Recommendation: Mastering Executive Transitions How to Speak Like a Spy Hi Reader, Andrew Bustamante asked an Australian entrepreneur one simple question: what's your annual revenue? Up to that point, the conversation had been green lights all the way. Bruce had happily talked about how he got started running care facilities and...

This week in the world’s #1 newsletter on leadership communication: Why You Need to Break the Frame On the Show: What to (Never) Say in Your First Week as a Leader Book Recommendation: How to Be Good at Life Why You Need to Break the Frame Hi Reader, Good boys and girls don't make it to the top. I know that sounds harsh, so let me explain. Every room has a frame: unwritten rules about who speaks first, what you wear and what you're allowed to say. Most of us follow these rules without...